BB(7): Difference between revisions
m (Small formatting change) |
(Changed the link to my Google Drive folder - I'm rearranging things) |
||
Line 222: | Line 222: | ||
| | | | ||
[https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1wniwrAuvsHfkvro8Tg65WAMNZEuIekzD @Iijil]<br/> | [https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1wniwrAuvsHfkvro8Tg65WAMNZEuIekzD @Iijil]<br/> | ||
[https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/ | [https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1yQFLcznvNzEF9uWXL1xkJhhfxPDtbC7x?usp=drive_link Terry Ligocki] | ||
|- | |- | ||
|05-09xxxx | |05-09xxxx | ||
Line 253: | Line 253: | ||
|{{TM|1RB0RE_1LC0LA_1LD0LC_0LE0LA_1RF0RG_1RD0LE_1RA1RZ}} | |{{TM|1RB0RE_1LC0LA_1LD0LC_0LE0LA_1RF0RG_1RD0LE_1RA1RZ}} | ||
|10 ↑↑ 114.60 | |10 ↑↑ 114.60 | ||
|[https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/ | |[https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1yQFLcznvNzEF9uWXL1xkJhhfxPDtbC7x?usp=drive_link Google Drive folder] | ||
|- | |- | ||
|14-16xxxx | |14-16xxxx | ||
Line 275: | Line 275: | ||
| | | | ||
[https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1kAvBebeF09CEVocCk5bGKlDJfRN8co_i?usp=sharing @gerbil5709]<br/> | [https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1kAvBebeF09CEVocCk5bGKlDJfRN8co_i?usp=sharing @gerbil5709]<br/> | ||
[https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/ | [https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1yQFLcznvNzEF9uWXL1xkJhhfxPDtbC7x?usp=drive_link Terry Ligocki] | ||
|- | |- | ||
|19xxxx | |19xxxx | ||
Line 322: | Line 322: | ||
|{{TM|1RB1RZ_1LC0RF_0LD1LB_1RD0LE_1RB1LE_1RG0RE_0RA0LE}} | |{{TM|1RB1RZ_1LC0RF_0LD1LB_1RD0LE_1RB1LE_1RG0RE_0RA0LE}} | ||
|10 ↑↑ 192.67 | |10 ↑↑ 192.67 | ||
[https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1yQFLcznvNzEF9uWXL1xkJhhfxPDtbC7x?usp=drive_link Google Drive folder] | |||
|- | |- | ||
|40-47xxxx | |40-47xxxx | ||
Line 353: | Line 353: | ||
| | | | ||
[https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1-csgJ5uSIX3SKlqTkSnhkUuEYLKgCw81 Tobiáš Brichta]<br/> | [https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1-csgJ5uSIX3SKlqTkSnhkUuEYLKgCw81 Tobiáš Brichta]<br/> | ||
[https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/ | [https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1yQFLcznvNzEF9uWXL1xkJhhfxPDtbC7x?usp=drive_link Terry Ligocki] | ||
|- | |- | ||
|50xxxx | |50xxxx | ||
Line 377: | Line 377: | ||
| | | | ||
[https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1kAvBebeF09CEVocCk5bGKlDJfRN8co_i?usp=sharing @gerbil5709]<br/> | [https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1kAvBebeF09CEVocCk5bGKlDJfRN8co_i?usp=sharing @gerbil5709]<br/> | ||
[https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/ | [https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1yQFLcznvNzEF9uWXL1xkJhhfxPDtbC7x?usp=drive_link Terry Ligocki] | ||
|- | |- | ||
|54-59xxxx | |54-59xxxx | ||
Line 386: | Line 386: | ||
|{{TM|1RB0LC_1LC1LD_1LA1LB_0LG1RE_0RF0RF_0RA1RE_1RZ1LA}} | |{{TM|1RB0LC_1LC1LD_1LA1LB_0LG1RE_0RF0RF_0RA1RE_1RZ1LA}} | ||
|10 ↑↑ 188.28 | |10 ↑↑ 188.28 | ||
[https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1yQFLcznvNzEF9uWXL1xkJhhfxPDtbC7x?usp=drive_link Google Drive folder] | |||
|- | |- | ||
|60-64xxxx | |60-64xxxx | ||
Line 399: | Line 399: | ||
| | | | ||
[https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1kAvBebeF09CEVocCk5bGKlDJfRN8co_i?usp=sharing @gerbil5709]<br/> | [https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1kAvBebeF09CEVocCk5bGKlDJfRN8co_i?usp=sharing @gerbil5709]<br/> | ||
[https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/ | [https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1yQFLcznvNzEF9uWXL1xkJhhfxPDtbC7x?usp=drive_link Terry Ligocki] | ||
|- | |- | ||
|65-68xxxx | |65-68xxxx | ||
Line 408: | Line 408: | ||
|{{TM|1RB0LD_0LC1RZ_1RA0RD_1RE1LD_1LF0RC_0LG1LE_1RG0LD}} | |{{TM|1RB0LD_0LC1RZ_1RA0RD_1RE1LD_1LF0RC_0LG1LE_1RG0LD}} | ||
|10 ↑↑ 192.67 | |10 ↑↑ 192.67 | ||
[https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1yQFLcznvNzEF9uWXL1xkJhhfxPDtbC7x?usp=drive_link Google Drive folder] | |||
|- | |- | ||
|69xxxx | |69xxxx | ||
Line 435: | Line 435: | ||
|{{TM|1RB0RB_1LC1RG_1RD1RC_1RE0RA_1LF0LB_1RF0LE_0RD1RZ}} | |{{TM|1RB0RB_1LC1RG_1RD1RC_1RE0RA_1LF0LB_1RF0LE_0RD1RZ}} | ||
|10 ↑↑ 228.78 | |10 ↑↑ 228.78 | ||
[https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1yQFLcznvNzEF9uWXL1xkJhhfxPDtbC7x?usp=drive_link Google Drive folder] | |||
|- | |- | ||
|80-81xxxx | |80-81xxxx | ||
Line 453: | Line 453: | ||
|{{TM|1RB1RF_0RC1RG_1LD1LE_0LE1LD_0RF0LC_1RA0LC_0RF1RZ}} | |{{TM|1RB1RF_0RC1RG_1LD1LE_0LE1LD_0RF0LC_1RA0LC_0RF1RZ}} | ||
|10 ↑↑ 286.17 | |10 ↑↑ 286.17 | ||
[https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1yQFLcznvNzEF9uWXL1xkJhhfxPDtbC7x?usp=drive_link Google Drive folder] | |||
|} | |} | ||
<nowiki>*</nowiki>The current BB(7) champion TM {{TM|1RB0RA_1LC1LF_1RD0LB_1RA1LE_1RZ0LC_1RG1LD_0RG0RF}}* was discovered by Pavel Kropitz in the enumeration of subtask 243308. The remaining subtasks in the 24xxxx range were enumerated and filtered by Andrew Ducharme. | <nowiki>*</nowiki>The current BB(7) champion TM {{TM|1RB0RA_1LC1LF_1RD0LB_1RA1LE_1RZ0LC_1RG1LD_0RG0RF}}* was discovered by Pavel Kropitz in the enumeration of subtask 243308. The remaining subtasks in the 24xxxx range were enumerated and filtered by Andrew Ducharme. | ||
[[Category:BB Domain]] | [[Category:BB Domain]] |
Revision as of 23:41, 17 July 2025
The 7-state, 2-symbol Busy Beaver problem, BB(7), refers to the unsolved 7th value of the Busy Beaver function. With the compilation of the Cryptid machine Bigfoot into a 7-state, 2-symbol machine in May 2024, we now know that we must solve a Collatz-like problem in order to solve BB(7).
The current BB(7) champion 1RB0RA_1LC1LF_1RD0LB_1RA1LE_1RZ0LC_1RG1LD_0RG0RF
(bbch) was discovered by Pavel Kropitz in May 2025, proving the lower bound:
History
Before 2025, the only known BB(7) champions were produced by hand, not by search. In 1964, Milton Green designed a machine that had sigma score 22,961. In 2014, Wythagoras modified a BB(6) champion to produce a machine that had sigma score .
In May 2025, mxdys shared C++ code that breaks up the BB(7) enumeration into 1 million subtasks which each run for about 2 minutes and leave ~100 holdouts each. Various folks on Discord have been investigating different sections of this domain to search for champions.
Within three days of the code's release, the Ligockis found three champions after applying their deciders to enumerator output. Shawn Ligocki found the first two, 1RB0RF_1LC0RE_1RD1LB_1LA1LD_0RA0LE_1RG0LB_1RZ1RB
(bbch) and 1RB1RA_1RC0LC_0LD1LG_1LF0LE_1RZ1LF_0LA1LD_1RA1LC
(bbch), with sigma scores of approximately 10 ↑↑ 22 and 10 ↑↑ 35. That evening, Terry Ligocki found 1RB0LG_1RC0RF_1LD1RZ_1LF0LE_1RA1LD_1LG1RE_0LB0LB
(bbch), with sigma score ~10 ↑↑ 46. A few days later, Pavel found a TM that outpaces all of them.
Pavel's champion is enumerated in subtask 243308.
Top Halters
Based on limited search through a subset of the 1 million subtasks from mxdys's code, the top 20 scoring known machines are:
TM | Approximate sigma score | Discoverer |
---|---|---|
1RB0RA_1LC1LF_1RD0LB_1RA1LE_1RZ0LC_1RG1LD_0RG0RF (bbch)
|
Pavel Kropitz | |
1RB1RZ_0RC0RE_1LD1LA_1LC0LG_0RF1LF_0RD1LF_1LB0LE (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 519.20 | Andrew Ducharme |
1RB1RZ_0RC0RE_1LD1LA_1LC0LG_0RF1LE_0RD1LF_1LB0LE (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 519.20 | Andrew Ducharme |
1RB1RZ_0RC0RE_1LD1LA_1LC0LG_0RF1LE_0RD0LG_1LB0LE (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 519.20 | @gerbil5709, Terry Ligocki |
1RB1RF_0RC1RG_1LD1LE_0LE1LD_0RF0LC_1RA0LC_0RF1RZ (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 286.17 | Terry Ligocki |
1RB0LE_1RC0RA_1RD0RC_1LE1LD_1LA0LF_0LA0LG_1RZ0RD (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 246.32 | @Iijil |
1RB1RZ_1RC0LE_0RD1RB_1LE1RA_1LF0LG_0LG0RG_1LB1RG (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 243.88 | @Iijil, Andrew Ducharme |
1RB0RB_1LC1RG_1RD1RC_1RE0RA_1LF0LB_1RF0LE_0RD1RZ (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 228.78 | Terry Ligocki |
1RB0LD_0LC1RZ_1RA0RD_1RE1LD_1LF0RC_0LG1LE_1RG0LD (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 192.67 | Terry Ligocki |
1RB1LA_1LC0RE_0LD1LB_1RD0LA_1RF0RA_0RG0LA_1RB1RZ (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 192.67 | Terry Ligocki |
1RB1LA_1LC0RE_0LD1LB_1RD0LA_1RF0RA_1RG0LA_0LE1RZ (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 192.67 | Terry Ligocki |
1RB1RZ_1LC0RE_0LD1LB_1RE0LA_1RF0RG_0RA0LG_1RB1LG (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 192.67 | Terry Ligocki |
1RB1RZ_1LC0RE_0LD1LB_1RE0LA_1RF0RG_0RG0LG_1RB1LG (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 192.67 | Terry Ligocki |
1RB1RZ_1LC0RE_0LD1LB_1RE0LG_1RF0RG_0RA0LG_1RB1LG (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 192.67 | Terry Ligocki |
1RB0LD_0LC1RZ_1RA0RD_1RE1LD_1LF0RC_0LG1LE_1RC0LD (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 192.67 | Andrew Ducharme |
1RB1LA_1LC0RE_0LD1LB_1RE1LG_1RF0LG_0RA0LA_0RF1RZ (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 192.67 | Andrew Ducharme |
1RB1LA_1LC0RF_0LD0RD_1RF1LE_1LB1RZ_1RG0RA_0RA0LA (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 192.67 | @C7X |
1RB1LA_1LC0RE_0LD1LB_1RE0LA_1RF0RA_0RG0LA_1RB1RZ (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 192.67 | @Iijil, Terry Ligocki |
1RB1LA_1LC0RE_0LD1LB_1RE0LA_1RF0RA_1RG0LA_0LE1RZ (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 192.67 | @Iijil, Terry Ligocki |
1RB1LA_1LC0RE_0LD1LB_1RE0LG_1RF0RA_0RA0LA_1RB1RZ (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 192.67 | @Iijil, Terry Ligocki |
The top 20 known halters with unique scores are:
TM | Approximate sigma score | Discoverer |
---|---|---|
1RB0RA_1LC1LF_1RD0LB_1RA1LE_1RZ0LC_1RG1LD_0RG0RF (bbch)
|
Pavel Kropitz | |
1RB1RZ_0RC0RE_1LD1LA_1LC0LG_0RF1LF_0RD1LF_1LB0LE (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 519.20 | Andrew Ducharme |
1RB1RF_0RC1RG_1LD1LE_0LE1LD_0RF0LC_1RA0LC_0RF1RZ (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 286.17 | Terry Ligocki |
1RB0LE_1RC0RA_1RD0RC_1LE1LD_1LA0LF_0LA0LG_1RZ0RD (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 246.32 | @Iijil |
1RB1RZ_1RC0LE_0RD1RB_1LE1RA_1LF0LG_0LG0RG_1LB1RG (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 243.88 | @Iijil, Andrew Ducharme |
1RB0RB_1LC1RG_1RD1RC_1RE0RA_1LF0LB_1RF0LE_0RD1RZ (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 228.78 | Terry Ligocki |
1RB1RZ_1LC0RE_0LD1LB_1RE0LA_1RF0RG_0RA0LG_1RB1LG (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 192.67 | Terry Ligocki |
1RB0LC_1LC1LD_1LA1LB_0LG1RE_1LD0RF_0RA1RE_1RZ1LA (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 188.28 | Terry Ligocki |
1RB0LC_1LC0LD_1LA1LB_0LG1RE_1LD0RF_0RA1RE_1RZ1LC (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 140.28 | @stokastic |
1RB0RF_1RC1RZ_0LD1RF_0RA1LE_0LC1LF_1LE0RG_0LE1RA (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 136.64 | Katelyn Doucette, Andrew Ducharme |
1RB0LG_0RC1RZ_1LD0LA_1RE1LE_1LC1RF_0RE0RA_0RF1LG (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 133.85 | @poppuncher |
1RB1RZ_1RC0RF_1LD1RB_1RG0LE_1LD0RA_1RE0LD_0RC1LF (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 129.24 | @Iijil |
1RB0LC_1RC0RG_1RD0LF_1RE0RF_1LA1RG_1LE1LF_1RZ1RD (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 126.20 | @stokastic |
1RB0LD_1RC1RA_0RD1RG_1LE1LF_0LF1LE_0RA0LD_0RA1RZ (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 124.86 | Terry Ligocki |
1RB1LF_1RC1RA_1LD0LD_1LA1LE_0LA0LD_1LG0RF_0LE1RZ (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 116.98 | Terry Ligocki |
1RB0RD_1RC0LA_0LA0LE_1RE1RZ_1RF0RA_1LG0LE_1LC0LG (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 116.05 | |
1RB0RD_1RC0RA_0RD1LD_0LE1LF_1LA0LG_0LC1LB_1LC1RZ (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 115.52 | @prurq |
1RB0RG_1LC0LE_1LD0LB_0LE1RE_0RA1RF_0RD1RC_1RD1RZ (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 114.83 | Andrew Ducharme |
1RB0RE_1LC0LA_1LD0LC_0LE0LA_1RF0RG_1RD0LE_1RA1RZ (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 114.60 | Shawn Ligocki |
1RB0RE_0RC1LC_0LD1LF_1LE0LG_1RA0RC_0LB1LA_1LB1RZ (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 114.57 | Andrew Ducharme |
Current Progress
This is a summary of the 1 million subtasks from mxdys's code that have been executed and their output processed by Shawn Ligocki's linear rule code.
Task range | Done by | Completed | # holdouts | Maximum Score TM | ~Sigma | Source | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
enumeration | linear rule | ||||||
00-01xxxx | @Iijil | Yes | Yes | 1,545,673 | 1RB0LE_1RC0RA_1RD0RC_1LE1LD_1LA0LF_0LA0LG_1RZ0RD (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 246.32 | Google Drive folder |
02-04xxxx |
@Iijil |
Yes | Yes | 2,279,734 | 1RB0LF_1RC1RA_1RD0RG_1LE1RZ_1LA0LF_1RA1LE_0RE1RG (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 93.81 | |
05-09xxxx |
@Iijil |
Yes | Yes | 3,889,955 | 1RB1RZ_1RC0LE_0RD1RB_1LE1RA_1LF0LG_0LG0RG_1LB1RG (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 243.88 | |
10-12xxxx | Andrew Ducharme | Yes | Yes | 2,708,888 | 1RB1RZ_0RC0RE_1LD1LA_1LC0LG_0RF1LE_0RD1LF_1LB0LE (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 519.20 | Google Drive folder |
13xxxx | Shawn Ligocki | Yes | Yes | 1,192,442 | 1RB0RE_1LC0LA_1LD0LC_0LE0LA_1RF0RG_1RD0LE_1RA1RZ (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 114.60 | Google Drive folder |
14-16xxxx | Andrew Ducharme | Yes | Yes | 2,701,637 | 1RB0LC_1LC1LD_1LA1LB_0LG1RE_0RF0LD_0RA1RE_1RZ1LA (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 188.28 | Google Drive folder |
17-18xxxx |
@gerbil5709 |
Yes | Yes | 1,898,156 | 1RB1LA_1LC0RE_0LD1LB_1RE0LA_1RF0RA_0RG0LA_1RB1RZ (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 192.67 | |
19xxxx |
Katelyn Doucette |
Yes | Yes | 1,601,356 | 1RB0RF_1RC1RZ_0LD1RF_0RA1LE_0LC1LF_1LE0RG_0LE1RA (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 136.64 | Google Drive folder |
20-23xxxx | @C7X | Yes | Yes | 4,528,827 | 1RB1LA_1LC0RF_0LD0RD_1RF1LE_1LB1RZ_1RG0RA_0RA0LA (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 192.67 | Google Drive folder |
24xxxx | Andrew Ducharme | Yes | Yes | 712,356 | 1RB0RA_1LC1LF_1RD0LB_1RA1LE_1RZ0LC_1RG1LD_0RG0RF (bbch)*
|
Google Drive folder | |
25-34xxxx | @stokastic | Yes | Yes | 10,339,816 | 1RB0LC_1LC0LD_1LA1LB_0LG1RE_1LD0RF_0RA1RE_1RZ1LC (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 140.28 | Google Drive folder |
35-39xxxx | Terry Ligocki | Yes | Yes | 4,894,047 | 1RB1RZ_1LC0RF_0LD1LB_1RD0LE_1RB1LE_1RG0RE_0RA0LE (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 192.67 | |
40-47xxxx | Andrew Ducharme | Yes | Yes | 6,181,327 | 1RB1RZ_0RC0RE_1LD1LA_1LC0LG_0RF1LF_0RD1LF_1LB0LE (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 519.20 | Google Drive folder |
48xxxx | @star | No | No | TBD | TBD | TBD | |
49xxxx |
Tobiáš Brichta |
Yes | Yes | 804,722 | 1RB0LG_1RC0RG_0LD1RE_1RD0RE_1LF1RB_0LA1RZ_1LC1LG (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 126.20 | |
50xxxx |
@prurq |
Yes | Yes | 797,224 | 1RB0RD_1RC0RA_0RD1LD_0LE1LF_1LA0LG_0LC1LB_1LC1RZ (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 115.52 | Google Drive folder |
51-53xxxx |
@gerbil5709 |
Yes | Yes | 3,016,175 | 1RB0LC_1LC0LD_1LA1LB_0LG1RE_0RF0RF_0RA1RE_1RZ1LC (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 140.28 | |
54-59xxxx | Terry Ligocki | Yes | Yes | 5,689,850 | 1RB0LC_1LC1LD_1LA1LB_0LG1RE_0RF0RF_0RA1RE_1RZ1LA (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 188.28 | |
60-64xxxx |
@gerbil5709 |
Yes | Yes | 3,817,876 | 1RB1RZ_0RC0RE_1LD1LA_1LC0LG_0RF1LE_0RD0LG_1LB0LE (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 519.20 | |
65-68xxxx | Terry Ligocki | Yes | Yes | 3,076,778 | 1RB0LD_0LC1RZ_1RA0RD_1RE1LD_1LF0RC_0LG1LE_1RG0LD (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 192.67 | |
69xxxx | @poppuncher | Yes | Yes | 1,053,119 | 1RB0LG_0RC1RZ_1LD0LA_1RE1LE_1LC1RF_0RE0RA_0RF1LG (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 133.85 | Google Drive folder |
70-71xxxx | @hipparcos | Yes | Yes | 1,899,094 | 1RB1RZ_1LC1RD_0LD0LC_1LE1RA_1LF0LE_1RF0RG_1RG0RD (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 77.50 | Github release |
72-79xxxx | Terry Ligocki | Yes | Yes | 7,627,514 | 1RB0RB_1LC1RG_1RD1RC_1RE0RA_1LF0LB_1RF0LE_0RD1RZ (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 228.78 | |
80-81xxxx | @xnoobspeakable | Yes | Yes | 1,537,533 | 1RB0LA_0RC1RZ_0RD0RG_1LE1RA_1LF1LD_1RG0RG_1RD1RC (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 74.85 | Google Drive folder |
82-99xxxx | Terry Ligocki | Yes | Yes | 15,673,786 | 1RB1RF_0RC1RG_1LD1LE_0LE1LD_0RF0LC_1RA0LC_0RF1RZ (bbch)
|
10 ↑↑ 286.17 |
*The current BB(7) champion TM 1RB0RA_1LC1LF_1RD0LB_1RA1LE_1RZ0LC_1RG1LD_0RG0RF
(bbch)* was discovered by Pavel Kropitz in the enumeration of subtask 243308. The remaining subtasks in the 24xxxx range were enumerated and filtered by Andrew Ducharme.